Ebook Download Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman
It will believe when you are going to pick this e-book. This motivating Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman publication can be reviewed completely in particular time depending on exactly how commonly you open up as well as read them. One to remember is that every book has their very own manufacturing to obtain by each viewers. So, be the great visitor and also be a much better individual after reading this book Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman
Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman
Ebook Download Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman
Exceptional Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman publication is constantly being the best friend for investing little time in your workplace, night time, bus, and almost everywhere. It will certainly be a good way to simply look, open, as well as read the book Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman while in that time. As recognized, encounter and skill don't always included the much cash to acquire them. Reading this publication with the title Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman will let you know much more points.
The factor of why you could get and get this Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman earlier is that this is guide in soft data form. You could check out the books Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman anywhere you want also you are in the bus, workplace, home, as well as various other areas. Yet, you might not have to relocate or bring guide Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman print any place you go. So, you will not have much heavier bag to carry. This is why your choice making far better concept of reading Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman is actually useful from this case.
Knowing the means how you can get this book Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman is additionally important. You have actually remained in right website to start getting this info. Obtain the Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman web link that we offer here as well as go to the web link. You could get the book Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman or get it as quickly as possible. You can promptly download this Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman after obtaining bargain. So, when you require the book rapidly, you could straight get it. It's so very easy and so fats, isn't it? You need to like to in this manner.
Simply connect your device computer system or gadget to the internet attaching. Get the modern-day technology making your downloading and install Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman completed. Even you don't wish to read, you could directly close guide soft documents and also open Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman it later on. You could also easily obtain the book almost everywhere, due to the fact that Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman it remains in your gadget. Or when being in the office, this Embattled Courage: The Experience Of Combat In The American Civil War, By Gerald Linderman is additionally advised to check out in your computer system gadget.
Linderman traces each soldier's path from the exhilaration of enlistment to the disillusionment of battle to postwar alienation. He provides a rare glimpse of the personal battle that raged within soldiers then and now.
- Sales Rank: #327588 in Books
- Color: Black
- Published on: 1989-04-17
- Released on: 1989-04-17
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.00" h x .90" w x 6.00" l, 1.37 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 368 pages
- ISBN13: 9780029197615
- Condition: New
- Notes: BRAND NEW FROM PUBLISHER! 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. Tracking provided on most orders. Buy with Confidence! Millions of books sold!
From Publishers Weekly
Linderman, history professor at the University of Michigan, describes the unreasonably high standards of morality prevalent in the nation at the start of the Civil War, citing for example a letter from General Custer assuring his wife that he has "not uttered a single oath, nor blasphemed, even in thought." According to Linderman, it was assumed on both sides that "the application of the moral values to the struggle would determine both the forms and the result of the war." By 1865 those soldiers who survived had learned otherwise. In this deep inquiry into the nature of courage (and cowardice) as defined by soldiers and civilians North and South, the author traces the breakdown of traditional values, the changing behavior of the soldiers and the "reconceptualization" of the war by veterans in their later years. Drawing on letters and memoirs, he reveals the common tendency of soldiers who became disillusioned during the fighting to experience an amazing reversion in postwar years to the blind idealism with which they originally went to war. Ironically, notes Linderman, the soldiers who went into the Spanish-American War carried the same values as those of 1861.
Copyright 1987 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Most helpful customer reviews
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
Interesting but questionable scholarship
By A Customer
Linderman has written a very interesting study of soldiers' psychological reactions to the Civil War. He discusses the viewpoints that people had going into the war and how they changed with the experience of combat. Perhaps the best part of the book is his study of Civil War veterans and the post-war reaction. Having said that, though, I found some of Linderman's scholarship problematic. He has a tendency to make broad sweeping statements ("All soldiers thought X...) which worries me. His bibliography is a little short and is slanted, as is some of his analysis, toward Northern contributors. Thus, he has very little to say about whether losing the war was psychologically different from winning it, which one would think would be the case. Overall, this is a useful book but I would read it in conjunction with other works on the subject -- McPherson's studies and *Seeing the Elephant* in particular.
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful.
I recommend it to anyone that wants a common's view of war!
By A Customer
I had purchased this book from a now defunct bookshop and was told from a friend in Cyberspace, that if I wanted an in depth understanding of the common soldier and his thoughts about combat and the war, I had to read Linderman's Embattled Courage. In the overleaf, Linderman quotes from Livy's History of Rome, XXX.20, "Nowhere do events correspond less to men's expectations than in war." Linderman uses this quote for his main thesis. He lets the soldiers themselves communicate their thoughts using their own letters to home. In the early chapters, Linderman examines the values of the soldiers and their will to fight for their respective causes. He focuses on the values that the soldiers carried with them to the front-manliness, godliness, duty, honor, and knightliness. In the letters from the soldiers, Linderman reveals how the young men believed that they had joined up to fight a civilized war where bravery and courage would protect them and guarantee victory. ! After the newness of battle wore off on the citizen soldiers, they began to learn what war actually was-killing, death by disease, and extreme boredom. The war itself is transformed in the latter years to what Sherman described as "total war." No longer were heroic charges the mainstay of attack. In 1864, the shovel was used to build trenches. War in the latter stage was not as glorious as the soldiers perceived it to be in 1861. The disillusionment of war is stated by Rice Bull of the 123rd NY: "The next afternoon on our way back to the picket line I saw fifteen unburied Confederate soldiers lying where they had fallen. It was not a pleasant sight to me, even though these man had been our enemies. I thought when I saw them, of the sorrow and grief there would be in fifteen homes somewhere; and for what had these young lives been sacrificed?...There should be some way to settle political differences without slaughtering human beings and wearing out the bod! ies and sapping the strength of those who may be fortunate ! enough to escape the death penalty." Rice Bull's late war attitudes differ greatly from that which many had in 1861. At war's end, men distanced themselves from all facets of the war. In the 1890's, as the soldiers faded into old age, they once again fondly reminisced about their war days. The GAR swelled from 30,000 men in 1878 to 428,000 men in 1890. Youngsters were told of the great days that the soldiers had in war. Ironically, those same soldiers who were so disillusioned in war at its closure were forgetting those lessons in their twilight years. Those soldiers who were to learn that their expectations of war in 1861, differed greatly from that which they saw in 1864-65, would return in the 1890's to re-perpetuate their prewar expectations thus creating the vicious cycle of war that has plagued man since the days of the Romans. Linderman's book was quite thought provoking for me and I recommend it to anyone that wants to reflect on what motivates men to fight ! in war and the lessons that never seem to be learned about the cruel realities of war. Ask yourself what peaks your interest in the Civil War, the Courageous War of 1861-63 or the Cruel War of 1864-65?****************Korky
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful.
Two Faces of Civil War Courage
By Robin Friedman
Gerald Linderman's "Embattled Courage" (1987) is an outstanding study of the motivation of soldiers during the American Civil War and of the values of the society to which they responded.
The book is in two broad sections. The first part of the book, titled "Courage's War" covers the early years of the war to about mid-1863 (the time of the climactic Union victories at Gettysburg and Vicksburg). During these years, Linderman sees the primary motivating factor of the war as courage and of individual effort. The soldier enlisting in the war effort -- and during the early years volunteers bore the overwhelming brunt of the effort- had concepts of personal bravery in the face of danger, fearlessness and commitment to duty and to a purpose. He believed that the actions of an individual mattered and could make a difference to the result of a battle. This was an idealistic concept and Linderman shows well how it was reinforced and complemented by concepts of manliness, comradeship, godliness and morality, chivalry, and the brotherhood of soldiers, which assumes a certain degree of respect for the enemy on the other side of the line. Linderman points out that the Civil War may have been the last conflict in which these ideals were taken seriously. They were dashed in WW I, and in the later phases of the Civil War itself.
The second part of the book, titled "A Perilous Education" shows how the initial idealism underlying the soldiers' war effort became hardened and tarnished with the stark reality of combat. The concept of courage didn't disappear but it changed and the soldiers became tougher and more realistic. On occasion cynicism and disilusion set in. The factors leading to this change in perspective were the horrors and deaths on the battlefield, reulting largely from the increased range of Civil War weaponry which helped make the traditional offensive charge (as at Fredericksburg, Gettysburg, and Cold Harbor) ineffective and death-dealing to the agressor. Other factors include the crude Civil War hospitals, with blood and amputation on every side, the long forced marches, the toll of disease in the camps, which led to twice as many deaths as did combat, the boredom of camp life, imprisionment in camps such as Andersonville, the lengthy character of the war, the confiict between volunteers and draftees, and the lack of food and supplies which led soldiers to "forage" from civilians and to strip valuables and clothes from the bodies of dead comrades and enemies. The civil war became a total, brutal war in the final two years. Stonewall Jackson early in the war, and Grant and Sherman subsequently, understood the total nature of the effort that was required to pursue this war.
The idealism with which the volunteers entered the war and their concept of individual effort changed radically when faced with the harshness of the war. This changed their understanding of themselves, the war effort, and their relationship to the civilian population.
There is a lengthy "epilogue' to the book which discusses the fate of the concept of courage following the war and how it evolved through the end of the 19th century. Broadly speaking, a certain nostalgia set in beginning in the 1880's when the original ideals of courage revived in memory and the hardships of the war effort receded.
Lindererman's book is well documented with contemporaneous accounts from the soldiers and with subsequent memoirs. It taught me a great deal about motivation in combat and how it changes with experience. Those interested in pursuing the subject further might be interested in James McPherson's "For Cause and Comrades", which takes issue with Linderman on certain points, and in David Blight's "Race and Reunion". The latter book develops the theme sketched in Linderman's epilogue by showing the effects of time on how people in the United States perceived the conflict of 1861 - 1865.
Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman PDF
Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman EPub
Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman Doc
Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman iBooks
Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman rtf
Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman Mobipocket
Embattled Courage: The Experience of Combat in the American Civil War, by Gerald Linderman Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar